E-Collar Training for Spaniels: A Tool, Not a Shortcut

E-collar training has become a volatile topic over the years. Anyone who speaks openly about it can become an easy target. I’m okay with that. I’m confident in what I know, and I’m comfortable sticking my neck out—because when an e-collar is used properly, it can be one of the most effective training tools we have. But used incorrectly, there is no worse tool.

So here’s our stance at Craney Hill Kennel:

We are e-collar trainers. We believe in e-collars as part of a complete training system—one tool in the training tool chest. The collar doesn’t replace foundation work. It doesn’t replace consistency. And it certainly doesn’t replace a relationship with your dog. In many real-world situations, you won’t be able to rely on an e-collar—so if the relationship and the basics aren’t there, the whole program has cracks.

We believe there’s no better training tool than a properly used e-collar… and no worse training tool than a misused one. Honestly, I wish people had to demonstrate proficiency before they were ever allowed to use one.

Like many professional kennels, we run training seminars that include instruction on proper e-collar use. But it’s important to understand something: there are multiple correct ways to use an e-collar. We use a combination of continuous and momentary stimulation. In the retriever world, you’ll often see approaches like indirect pressure. You’ll hear terms thrown around like “positive” and “negative,” and plenty of people will argue definitions instead of focusing on results and correctness. The point is: I’m not the only person that knows how to properly use an e-collar, and the way we use it on our flushing dogs isn’t the only way to use it.

But if you truly want to learn how to use an e-collar properly, don’t start with YouTube comments and opinions. Start with a professional trainer—and go watch them work. A skilled e-collar trainer should be able to explain what they’re doing, why they’re doing it, and what they’re watching in the dog.

Ask them real questions: Have you tested the collar on yourself—neck, wrist, ankle—so you understand what it actually feels like? Have you tested a bark collar appropriately so you understand what it does? What manufacturer do you trust and why? Do you only use one collar, or do you match the product to the dog and the job?

Those questions matter, because fit and contact matter. A collar that feels strong under the chin may not be felt at all when it shifts a quarter inch to the side. That becomes critical when you’re making a fast decision: is the dog truly blowing you off, or is the dog not feeling the collar? Are you trusting the light on the transmitter—or reading the dog?

There are also real equipment differences that most people never think about. Some collars have a delay from when you push a stimulation button until the stimulation turns on. Some have a delay on when it turns off. Some “continuous” settings aren’t truly continuous. Some units shut off at 8 seconds while others shut off at 10. Range claims on packaging don’t reflect real field conditions.

And here’s a common-sense point that gets ignored: if a collar claims a one-mile range, who can actually see their dog a mile away? And if you can’t see your dog, why would you be stimulating it?

Once you accept that you need professional guidance, then we can talk features—because features matter, and they should match the way you train.

Here’s what we look for. Most e-collars now have variable stimulation of at least seven levels. Your dog will certainly be able to be trained with one of those levels. Remember that a level one on e-collar A may be “hotter” or milder than level one on e-collar B. The collars that work best for us have a “jump” feature. That means I have one button that stimulates the dog at a working level, and another button that stimulates at a higher level without having to take my eyes off the dog and move the dial mid-action.

I want an e-collar that is true continuous stimulation. That means when stimulation is turned on, it stays on even when I increase the stimulation level. Some collars actually turn off when you increase the level, and you have to take your finger off the button and restart the stimulation.

People should only consider e-collars that have a waterproof receiver AND a waterproof transmitter. Most e-collars now use rechargeable batteries, and that’s what we want.

We do not rely on vibration, tone, or other “positive” features. Those are concessions manufacturers have made to improve public perception. The fact is, we train bird dogs. If anyone thinks a tone or vibration is going to stop a bird dog in the cattail slough when it’s hot on a pheasant, they are mistaken. And if a dog comes off a pheasant due to a vibration or some other “positive” tone, then that is not the kind of dog we want to build.

The e-collar should fit snug enough that you can just slide two fingers under the collar.

If you’re going to research anything, spend most of your time researching someone you can learn from. Don’t believe people that say you can’t use an e-collar around birds or in other situations. We use an e-collar in all situations. We have stimulated dogs with a bird in their mouth. If used properly, you can use an e-collar in all situations and have a dog that is exciting. It will not show evidence that it was trained with an e-collar.

When we hold out an e-collar at the front of the kennel, our dogs run up front to put their head through the collar. Now that is what I call POSITIVE training!

The e-collar can help reinforce standards—but it will never replace trust. A great bird dog comes from clarity, repetition, and a relationship that holds up when the collar

isn’t on. If you want help building that kind of dog, visit spanieltraining.com to learn more about our program.

Explore Our Training Program

---

Build the dog.

Build the standard.

Build the partnership.